Dmitry Orlov

Dmitry Orlov 

C l u b O r l o v | Certified AI-Free

3 068subscribers

470posts

The Language of Diplomacy or the Language of Revenge?

I recently did something I hadn't done in years: I took the family on a holiday trip. We boarded a train in St. Petersburg and 34 hours later we were in Simferopol, Crimea. A tour bus then took us across the coastal mountain range to Yalta, where we spent an entire week hiking in the mountains and visiting nearby royal palaces which had survived World War II intact with all of the furnishings and the landscaping because the invading Germans first wanted to claim them for themselves and then didn't have time to mine them before being driven out by the Red Army.
One of these palaces, in Livadia, was where the post-war Yalta conference was held by Stalin, Rosevelt and Churchill. At that conference, lots of details of post-war Europe were sorted out and signed into international law, allowing the great powers of the US and the USSR to keep the peace throughout the rest of the century. (Heavens only knows why that old drunk Churchill was even invited, since by then Britain was no longer a world power.)
It is hard to imagine that such a conference, including contemporary American or European leaders, could be held today. None of them seem the least bit capable of diplomacy — certainly not Trump and certainly not any of the political midgets currently in charge throughout Europe. Trump recently made himself hoarse by yelling at Iranians over the phone. That is not the language of diplomacy, which must be quiet, thoughtful and respectful. And this is sad indeed, because diplomacy and international law are the only mechanisms that humanity has been able to evolve to avoid endless, mindless slaughter.
Let us go back in time to where it all started: in autumn of 1648, in Münster. In a hall smelling of wax and mildew, papers were signed. The war had lasted thirty years. Those who were young when it had started were by then old and gray. Those who had believed that God was on their side had seen God disappear in the smoke rising from their burning towns and villages.
Germany had lost half of its population. Wolves roamed the streets of cities where only yesterday bells had rung from belfries. Soldiers, unable to remember any life other than war, didn't know where to go or what to do.
The diplomats signed papers. They had come to understand something essential: a war in which the enemy is treated not as a man but as the Devil devours all those who started it. A king who is treated as a legitimate target ceases to be a king. He becomes cannon fodder. This lesson had cost three million lives. Europe had paid for it in blood; enough blood had been shed for Europe to remember the lessons for almost four centuries.
The lessons were all simple. Killing kings is stupid because corpses can't capitulate. Mistreating emissaries is worse than a crime — it is a mistake! Who would you then sign peace treaties with? A war without end is a defeat for both sides. That is why the victors must spare the vanquished, and their families. The vanquished must be given the opportunity to surrender with dignity, otherwise they will fight to the death — theirs and yours both. Negotiators must be inviolable: one act of disrespect toward an ambassador is a prelude to a hundred years of murder. Neutral countries must be left alone: ​​unnecessary enemies automatically produce unnecessary graves for your own soldiers. This isn't morality — it is engineering. As in chess, the king must remain the king, even after losing the game. Burning down the chessboard is never a good option.
But three centuries later, in 1945, Europe was in ruins once again. This time, there were 50 million dead. Ruined cities smelled of smoke. The war lasted for just six years, but killed many more people than the Thirty Years' War because of improvements in killing technology.
At Nuremberg, the vanquished were judged — not for losing, mind you, but for not playing by the rules. There followed forty years of the Cold War, complete with missiles aimed at each other, hotlines, arms limitation treaties... The warring sides did not dare to fire on each other or to provoke the other side to the point of firing because they remembered the lessons: a shooting war does not lead to victory. It leads to a pile of ashes. This system worked not because everyone agreed with it or liked it, but because violating its rules was much more expensive than compliance.
But then the USSR left the game. There followed three and a half decades of impunity and three and a half decades of mayhem. A few months ago Iranian representatives attempted to negotiate in good faith; they were then killed by an air strike. The Iranians regrouped and sent in new representatives; they are now dead too. People in the West take in this sort of news with their morning coffee, not understanding what they have just read. Oil is up and that's bad, they think. It doesn't occur to them that they are some kind of dead too. They think that impunity is now the norm. There was Kosovo, then Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, Libya... and now Iran. And nothing happened, right? Something did happen — just not to them yet. Nobody in the West remembers Münster and the Thirty Year War. No one thinks about how a king who becomes a target ceases to be a king. That the loser, left with no way out, will fight to the last. That a negotiator, once betrayed, will never negotiate again.
Imagine a soldier from the Thirty Years' War. He doesn't know what he is fighting for. He only knows that his village was burned down, his family is gone, and the enemy is everywhere. He expects no mercy from anyone and he will give no mercy to anyone. Now imagine a world where there are millions of such soldiers, where every man on the losing side is a suicide bomber and where every attempt to get the situation under control only multiplies the numbers of the enemy because there is no trust and no one left who is neutral. This is not some sort of forecast; this is just the well forgotten past which is, inevitably, going to come back.
There are 90 million people in Iran and they know how to wait. They have allies among the 300 million Shia Moslems and they have prepositioned infrastructure in countries whose names you've heard on television. They no longer have reasons to negotiate. They have only reasons for revenge. When revenge becomes the only language spoken, perhaps it will be time to remember Münster and the diplomats who signed a peace treaty because they understood: a game without rules is a game without winners.
The blocking here is getting silly, with my VPN on I can't log into Boosty. I turn it off and get to where it asks for my verification code... which it sends by Telegram. So I have to turn ON the VPN to get the code. After that I can leave the VPN on and it works.
Daniel K., it's all just bumps in the road. I just moved our blog from Telegram to our own server. BIG hassle building and installing the software, but now some official is happier.
Jerry Durand, paraphrasing Shakrspeare' Fool, in 'King Lear', Act 1, Scene 4: Truth gets beaten out of the room into the kennel, whilst the lapdogs lie next to the fireplace and are allowed to stink.
It takes effort to beat the lapdogs. The reward is the company and wisdom of Truth.
There is no honor among bankers; profit is the justification for everything.
Barb Stapleton, I’m afraid we are past that point. Perhaps some lower level minions are still chasing dollars but Thiels, Masks, Gates of this world are chasing power and depopulation. It is more than money for them. If they wanted, they could have shared a tiny bit of profit with like-minded scum “elites” in China and/or Russia which would have secured them decades of comfortable existence. Instead they embarked on the quest of world domination worthy of the most corniest of Bond villains with projects such as C-19 or war against Russia in Russia’s backyard.
Marx and Lenin had a better grasp of History. We negotiate with bombs! says the last avatar minishyster for war...go figure!
Where’s the photos of your tour? Please share them with us. 
Dmitry Orlov, your son is extremely tall or inside a helicopter or drone.
Karaoke Vox, both!beaming_face
This rhymes perfectly with something a bit further from the past, Romans kept killing Parthian negotiators and break the treaties, in similar abject ways as the recent events. This resulted in the coming of the Sassanid dynasty that wouldn't take this kind of treatment from Rome this coincides with the end of Roman Empire and its worst crisis. The Sassanids managed major features like making a stool out of a live Roman emperor and pouring molten gold into his orifices.
Ed, Parthians were not Persian! Parthians were a Scythian tribe from Central Asia whereas Persians were from the Pars (Fars) region of Iran.
Dmitry Orlov, Thanks for the correction. 
Dmitry Orlov "(Heavens only knows why that old drunk Churchill was even invited, since by then Britain was no longer a world power.)."
An Interesting question 
I recently read that "ALL" wars are bankers wars.
Could he have been representing the power behind the Curtain:
" The City of London, or "Square Mile," is the historic, financial, and administrative heart of London, founded by the Romans in AD 43. It operates as an autonomous city-state within the UK with its own mayor (Lord Mayor) and police force. Known as a major global financial hub." 
Joe Cassese, the statement "All wars are banker wars" represents a most unhealthy focus on money. If all you can see is money, then bankers certainly block your view of the world.
Dmitry Orlov, I agree. Unfortunately, the financial elite has a different worldview than you or I. How did you put it " …, diplomacy and international law are the only mechanisms that humanity has been able to evolve to avoid endless, mindless slaughter." 
However, these Psychopathic Homicidal Maniacs couldn't care less about human slaughter as long as they maintain their position at the head of the line.
AD 43 to 2026.
Dmitry, great article and fully agreed!
What action would shock the West into conforming with reality? Endless ‘measured’ responses from the non-West don’t seem to break through the megalomania. So is this it? The whole world must suffer an oil shock and an economic depression?
John Zwiebel, That is a fine passage of written work, you are awake John Zwiebel
Ruari Foster, suffer an oil shock.we are living on an oil party, the hang-over will eventually come. And we are all partying
Very, very good reading. Thank you, Dmitry.
Wonderful analysis!!
Maybe this war on Iran is part of "The Great Reset" and the plan of a "New World Order". Part of the idea to "Build Back Betta".
As these terms are bloviated by the barking seal middle managers posing as politicians, on an ongoing basis.
Ian Dawson, Both 6uild 6ack 6etter and 6ig 6eautiful 6ill have dubious monikers if you know what I mean. In the Epstein Empire everything is possible. 
Ian Dawson, somebody should write a book called "Mindful Stupidity" or "Purposeful Self-Destruction" or something. I am sure that some self-destructive idiots would snap up the whole print run.
Dimitry, how about "COVID-19: THE GREAT RESET"?
Oh shit, that title is already taken.
This excellent document and explanation from Dmitry Orlov, thank you Dmitry!, is wonderfully complemented reading the following: " The emerging arquitecture of the interregnum" by Nel Bonilla and FuturEarly
I know you're not a Twitter guy, but you might find him interesting, if difficult to understand. (by "kitchen," he seems to mean himself) https://x.com/i/status/2046741614836555847
Just out of interest which way did your train enter Crimea? Through russian occupied Ukraine or west directly out of Russia (near Krasnodor and Novorossiysk). I heard about 6 months ago that the russians had rebuilt the train lines through russian occupied Ukraine down to Crimea - or atleast towards Crimea but not sure if that was just for military and not civilian.
Dmitry Orlov, Do you mean pre 2022 borders?
Barnaby, I mean the borders of the Russian Federation. To quote Putin: "Russia's borders do not end anywhere."
Dear Demitry.
This is a beautiful bit of writing.
Please make it free so it may be circulated.
This is the highest compliment I can give it.
Hi Dmitry, sorry to ask. But what are the chances nukes are fake? Nuclear energy is fake? How does anybody really know?
Matthew, same as the chances that the Earth is flat. 
It is not quite true that the language of diplomacy developed by the „Westfälischer Friede“ is not being discussed and strongly recommended in Europe. For me as a reader of the non-corporate media the topic is covered frequently: An example ( quite long though , see chapter “Die europäische Weltordnung“) is https://multipolar-magazin.de/artikel/niedergang-des-westens. And there are many more authors resp. interviewees who remind their readers of this European diplomatic achievement. Juli Zeh, one of the most well-known German fiction writers, also I found very clear words on a diplomacy of non-interference in the spirit of the peace of Westphalia, that is non-interference in the inner affairs of other countries : https://www.srf.ch/kultur/gesellschaft-religion/bestsellerautorin-im-interview-juli-zeh-die-weltpolitik-ist-kein-spielfeld-fuer-moral. But of course this discussion doesn’t take place in our mainstream media.
Translate a moral of this historical story to modern reality, could make a potential picture of US, after economical collapse. Just I am slightly pessimistic.beaming_face
Subscription levels4

Spare Change

$1.75 per month
This subscription level is intended mostly for people of limited means: students, pensioners and the unemployed.

Supporter

$4.8 per month
Thank you for your support.

Enabler

$8.1 per month
You are the wind under my wings.

Patron

$15 per month
Your generosity is my inspiration.
Go up