EN
Dmitry Orlov
Dmitry Orlov
2 359 subscribers
goals
1 440.04 of $ 24 732 money raised
Help me keep more of my posts open to the public.

Clown World Diplomacy

Show post
Show more comments
I live in Sweden and have payment problems again - last time was some years agao and affected many. I pay my subscription in USD and using VISA. In January there was no problem but now suddenly Boosty mail me "
An error occurred while trying to renew the subscription". Is here anyone else having problems?
Show replies (2)
avatar
It is hard to understand the clown show, but it does seem to move Agenda 2030 forward. Could there be system to the madness?
Show replies (5)
avatar
Login problems. For the past week I've not been able to login via phone # (I don't use any of the promoted social networks > Google/YT/Twitch). No code received via text/SMS on iPhone. After many attempts Boosty support advised login code was accessible via browser only; at Telegram. Perhaps others had login... a week without Dmitry!!!?  SweatDroplets
Show replies (4)
avatar
Thank you for such a hard-hitting article.
I hope the right people read it.
avatar
Everything is so clearly laid out from the Russian side.
Straightforward. Russia has so far done exactly what they have said they are going to do. Why don’t our ‘leaders’ believe them?
I think they’re not clowns but idiots.
I know a few rodeo clowns. They are the most trustworthy and fearless men. This is an insult to them. Fools, idiots and sold outs, yes.
Show replies (1)
avatar
So, the US and its proxy-- the by now very former ukraine-- start a war, despite a thousand years of historical evidence against them, with the Russian Army. On the Russian Army's own turf. 
They then lose that war, badly. 
Then the losers hold a meeting and agree that the proxy must cease fire and stop being defeated before they run out of men and ammunition. 
Then both losers demand that the army who's just defeated them (!?) also cease fire, or else they're going to continue providing the woefully defeated proxy with 1990s military equipment to replace the stuff that the Russian Army has already destroyed. And will also resume the provision of 3ISR intelligence data that hasn't made a jot of difference to the eventual outcome, already known years in advance by anyone who knows anything about what's historically happened to anyone or anything who's ever been deluded enough to... well... take on the Russian Army?
Am I getting all that right?
Show replies (2)
We are told now, there is a "ball" and a "court" and this ball is now on the "Russian side" of this court. Do they really expect a "Minsk 3" to be taken seriously? Remember what non- agreement-capable means.
avatar
Maybe it's not THE ball. Just a ball, and there are more of them.
What is a clown without its toys?
avatar
That witty comparison between a diplomat and a lady may be an old joke but it's new to me and instantly memorable. I'll be sharing that one at every opportunity. 
Diplomacy requires reasonable people to think rationally and yo be honest with each other. It cannot be used effectively in engagements with dishonest, unreasonable people. That's why stable societies need to be employ powerful physical forces such as the police to deal with criminals, especially violent ones. 
Sometimes there IS a military solution. 
avatar
Hello Dmitry, I thought I'd look you up three years after you moved off Patreon. I've missed your pithy and darkly humorous insights.
You mentioned: "Why should the residents of Odessa have their rights of self-determination denied while the residents of Donetsk have been granted theirs? Such arbitrariness would be impossible to justify..."
In the period from 2014 to 2022 we could have asked:
"Why should the residents of Donetsk and Lugansk have their rights of self-determination denied while the residents of Crimea have been granted theirs?" Was such arbitrariness impossible for Russia to justify for 8 years?
avatar
I agree with the right to self-determination, and wouldn't that be the best place for any talks between Putin and Trump to begin? Putin and Trump could agree to jointly observe as Nikolaev, Odessa, Sumy and Kiev regions conduct referendums to self-determine. Heck, rerun referendums in Crimea, Donetsk and Lugansk with the same observers if needed. Surely this is better than continuing to fight.
avatar
Nathan, yes, the same logic would apply. As far as the rest of it, we are not in a position to offer advice to Putin or to Trump. The suggestion to re-run referenda in the new Russian regions now, after they have been written into the Russian constitution is... funny, I guess.
avatar
Dmitry, this is a place for discourse, for sharing of ideas and interacting with the ideas you share in your essays. Surely we can do that without you chiding us as if we offer advice directly to world leaders. My point is that, for the first time in four years, Putin has an American leader who is keen to stop the conflict. Showing the world that self determination is at the root of the SMO has to be better than not caring that the other guys with nukes don't understand what is really going on.
It's my understanding that several referendums were conducted in Donetsk and Lugansk since the collapse of the USSR, and true self determination shouldnt stop just because they have joined another federation. 
avatar
Nathan, discussion is pointless unless the Russian prrspective is properly understood. Russia won, the US lost. Losers don't get to offer unsolicited advice. If that seems harsh, then perhaps you need to have your country invaded.

Subscription levels

Spare Change

$ 1,49 per month
This subscription level is intended mostly for people of limited means: students, pensioners and the unemployed.

Supporter

$ 4,5 per month
Thank you for your support.

Enabler

$ 8,1 per month
You are the wind under my wings.

Patron

$ 14,9 per month
Your generosity is my inspiration.
Go up